Registration / Login
text version
War and Peace

 Hot news

Touring the Backyard: Putin Pays Central Asia a Visit
Donbass blockade is finishing off Poroshenko and Akhmetov
If US throws Ukraine under the bus, will Moscow reciprocate?
Military Situation Remains Tense In Eastern Ukraine
Main page » Analysis » View
Printable version
The magic of bankers
03.02.17 22:29 Economics

Rudo de Ruijter

Independent researcher

Netherlands

If you dont know how banks work, you will never be able to understand the world.

Juggle money out of the hat. Of course, bankers cannot. But what they can is juggle numbers out of the hat and make everybody believe this is money.

bankers hat

In a nutshell this is how bankers work. The trick is simple and well unveil it in a moment. But unfortunately, it doesnt stop there.

The little trick has tremendous consequences for our society. For when you are able to fool people that easily and when you also get well paid for that, you dont want to stop. You can make people work for you, put politicians to your carriage and manage the whole society at will to put into circulation more and more of these profitable numbers. And as long as people dont understand where there problems come from, the bankers can quietly continue to make us work for them. And each year a bit more.

bankers carriage

The characteristic of todays banking system is the creation of balances for loans. This is done with a line of bookkeeping on the banks balance sheet, in which the debt of the borrower is written as an asset and a matching amount for the borrower as a liability. Put otherwise, the bank books the loan as a mutual debt acknowledgement. The borrower acknowledges he owes an amount to the bank (debit) and the bank acknowledges it owes a matching amount to the borrower (credit). The sheet stays balanced and the borrower now disposes of a bank balance. [1]

Buy a car?

Example: John wants to buy a car and borrows 2000 euro from the bank.

Loan balance payment account

Now, John has still no money in his purse. [2] But he has a bank balance, with which he can order his bank to pay the car for him. He gives this order with his bank card.

pay car

Most people will think, that if the banks owe us money, they have it. They take care of our payments, dont they? Well, lets have a closer look at that.

Payments via the bank

We can give the bank orders to execute payments for us with a bank card, check, pre-authorised payment, transfer formular or via internet banking. When the bank pays something for us, a part of our balance disappears.

Example: Johns payment order in favour of the car seller. John is with the Green Bank and the car seller with the Blue Bank.

Payment Green Bank to Blue bank

When we order a payment in favour of someone with another bank, our bank has to transfer the money to that other bank. The benificiary does not receive any money, but, instead, he receives a new balance from his own bank.

In the example above the Green bank pays 2,000 euros to the Blue Bank. That is the way it goes in theory.

However, in the practice of the daily payments between banks, in average all incoming and outgoing payments cancel each other!!!

Payment orders

Example:

Suppose there are 3 banks in the country. Bank A services 50 percent of the population, Bank B 30 percent and Bank C 20 percent. Lets say, on a day, all payment orders of the whole population together amounts to 100 million euros.

Then, in average, half of these orders (50 mln) come from customers of Bank A. They are in favour of customers of whom half are with Bank A itself  (25 nln), while the rest has to be paid to Bank B (30/50 of the remaining 25 mln, which makes 15 mln) and Bank C (20/50 of 25 mln, which makes 10 mln.)

If we repeat these calculations for the payment orders from customers from Bank B and C, we see that - in average - all mutual payments between the banks cancel each other out.

At the end of the day, only the minor differences that occur in reality are effectively paid. Banks need very little money to execute all payment orders.

Note that banks supply new loans continuously, again in proportion to their size. The average payments that come forth out of the use of these loans, will also cancel each other out in the same way.

  • Nearly empty vaults

Indeed, banks have very little money. For each euro they owe us, they have just a few cents. The rest of the money doesnt exist. Neither in a vault somewhere, nor at the central bank. What we have in our bank accounts is almost completely thin air.

Empty vault

To establish this you dont even have to have access to the vault. It is published in the annual report of the banks.

ING 2011

Click for enlargement

Here an extract of the annual report of ING of 2011. The cash of the bank, together with the balance they have at the central bank, amounts to 28 billion. The money the bank owes to customers amounts to 479 billion. So they dont even dispose of 6 cents for each euro they owe them. In the right column you can see this proportion was even worse in 2010. Then they had in average 2 cents for each euro they owed to their customers.

The little bit of money banks have serves for the payments between banks as well as for handing out cash to customers who ask for it. And if some day the bank hasnt enough cash, the customers simply have a run on bad luck.

ATM

  • Purchase power

A bank balance is an individual agreement between a bank and a customer. As long as the bank doesnt fail, our balance, together with our cash money, determines how much we can purchase. In the economy the bank balances have largely taken over the function of money. (Most economists havent had a financial training and dont make a difference between money and bank balances. They designate the amounts in our bank accounts as money in circulation.)

  • Installments

When a borrower pays a part of his debt, both his debt and his bank balance decreases. This way the borrowed amount progressively disappears again.

Résumé

So far we have seen how bankers fool us with loans. We dont borrow any money, but we receive a bank balance, or to say it otherwise, a recognition by the bank it still owes us the money. And although, in theory, we have the right to claim the money, our bank only has a tiny little percentage of what it owes to its customers. The rest of the money doesnt exist.

When we order our bank to make a payment for us, a part of our balance disappears and the bank pays the amount to the bank of the favoured person. (At least in theory, in practice all payments between banks cancel each other for the greater part.) The beneficiary doesnt receive the money. Instead, he receives a new balance of his own bank.

Will be continued soon...

Sources and explanations:

[1] Banks dont like to give openness about their working methods. This is probably because - ethically speaking - they are based on deception and swindle. People think they borrow money, but they are fooled with numbers from the hat. The method is explained in university books of the faculty of Finance, like in "Money, Financial Markets & Financial Institutions" by C. van Ewijk & L.J.R. Scholtens (Wolters Noordhoff, in Dutch). A bit more cryptically you can also read it in a pdf of the Bank of England: "Whenever a bank makes a loan, it simultaneously creates a matching deposit in the borrower’s bank account."

http://www.courtfool.info/Bank_of_England_prereleasemoneycreation.pdf 

[2] In financial science bank balances are often called near money. With a bank balance you cannot pay. You can only order your bank to make a payment for you.

30 January 2017

 
 Orphus: ORPS

Archive
Forum

     .

 Exclusiveread more rss

» Addition by Subtraction, (x, y)↦x−y
» Too Little, Too Late, will there be a Romanov ending for the Sudairi Seven?
» Week 21: When economic arguments end, the arms race begins
» Is Germany losing yet another world war?
» The Islamic State (ISIS) is Made in America: The Pentagon had Planned the Fall of Mosul and Ramadi in 2012
» Has Merkel Been Abandoned?
» The Islamic State and Chaos in the Greater Middle East
» Council on Foreign Relations Grand Strategy: China Must Be Defeated, The TPP Is Essential to Undermining China

 Newsread more rss

» Integrating the Army Into the US Approach to the Pacific
» Russian jets mistakenly bomb US-backed forces in Syria
» Touring the Backyard: Putin Pays Central Asia a Visit
» ISIS Changes Format of War in Iraq Using Partisan Methods
» Great Wall of the EU: China at the gates
» Donbass blockade is finishing off Poroshenko and Akhmetov
» Israel targeted under law passed to help 9/11 families sue Saudis
» Morocco threatens to cut EU ties if farm deal flounders

 Reportsread more rss

» The Cowardice of Aung San Suu Kyi
» EU Steps Up The Pace For Cashless Society In 2017/18
» Islamic States Khorasan Province, 2 Years on
» Can Afghanistans Economy Rebound in 2017?
» Trump triumphed due to downward mobility
» Americas Secret African Drone War Against the Islamic State
» Putin Goes Ballistic In Syria, Obliterates The USAs Secret Mideast Strategy
» Grassroots Fascism: The War Experience of the Japanese People

 Commentariesread more rss

» Moscows wriggle room shrinking vis-à-vis Trump
» The $2 Trillion Gamble That Saudi Arabia Cannot Win
» Frances election in total chaos for the mainstream
» If US throws Ukraine under the bus, will Moscow reciprocate?
» Russian Mercenaries In Syria And Around The World
» Did Bayer AG do a Sly Deal on Glyphosate with EU Commission?
» The road to democracy
» Why Pakistan let out a Top Secret

 Analysisread more rss

» The cancer of bankers
» Will Trump Destroy the Euro?
» The magic of bankers
» Pakistan and China: Dont Fear Chabahar Port
» South Africas Opposition See Eye to Eye with Trump
» Rex Tillerson and the Myths, Lies and Oil Wars to Come
» Incipient Hybrid War in South Central Africa and Mozambique
» Trump Killed TPP. Whats Next For Trade in Asia?
 
text version 2006-2016 Inca Group "War and Peace"